Copyright ©IFS 2024 | All Rights Reserved.
Fires pose a significant threat, demanding effective suppression methods, especially for sensitive environments. Clean agent systems offer a crucial solution, with two prominent types: Hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) and Novec fluids. While both offer clean and effective fire suppression, key differences exist, making one more suitable than the other depending on the application.
Both HFC and Novec systems primarily extinguish fires by absorbing heat, interrupting the combustion process. Some HFCs also have a minor chemical effect on the flame. Crucially, when properly engineered and installed, they do not displace oxygen to hazardous levels in occupied spaces. However, proper ventilation after discharge is always recommended.
Feature | HFCs | Novec Fluids (e.g., Novec 1230) |
---|---|---|
Chemical Makeup |
Hydrofluorocarbons (H, F, C) |
Fluoroketones |
Environmental Impact |
Generally have a higher Global Warming Potential (GWP) and longer atmospheric lifetime. |
Significantly lower GWP and shorter atmospheric lifetime. More environmentally friendly. |
Cost |
Historically, often lower upfront cost. |
Can have a higher initial cost, but long-term benefits (environmental regulations, etc.) may offset this. |
Performance |
Highly effective on Class A, B, and C fires. |
Equally effective on Class A, B, and C fires. |
Regulations |
Increasingly subject to regulations and phase-downs due to environmental concerns in some regions. |
Generally not subject to the same level of regulatory scrutiny due to lower environmental impact. |
Safety |
Safe for use in occupied spaces when engineered and used correctly. Proper ventilation after discharge is essential. |
Safe for use in occupied spaces when engineered and used correctly. Proper ventilation after discharge is essential. |
Benefits Shared by Both
Both are used in:
Consider these factors:
Both HFC and Novec clean agents offer excellent fire protection for sensitive environments. However, the significantly lower environmental impact of Novec fluids makes them increasingly the preferred choice, especially for new installations and upgrades. While HFCs remain a viable option for some applications, understanding the key differences is essential for making an informed decision. Always consult with a qualified fire suppression system professional for proper design, installation, and maintenance.